The Porch Light Decision

Disclaimer: Devoted Grandma is reader-supported. If you purchase anything through my site, I may receive a small commission (at no cost to you). Thank you.

Print this article

Every Sunday for 42 years, Marlene Simmons kept the porch light on.

In the small town of Stillwater, Oklahoma, that porch light was more than a beacon. It was a tradition. Her late husband, Bill, always said, “You never know who might need a place to land.” So she kept it on for her kids, the neighbors, old friends who might be passing through, even after Bill passed fifteen years ago.

But lately, that light had begun to feel less like a welcome sign and more like a burden.

Her son Todd had moved back in two years ago, “just for a few months” after a layoff, and somehow, he was still there. He borrowed money. He left messes. He played the TV too loud. And every time she tried to bring up moving forward, he reminded her, “You’re always telling people this house is home.”

Then one night, after a long day at the clinic volunteering, Marlene came home to find her living room cluttered with Todd’s friends, empty pizza boxes, and not a word of greeting.

She stood in the doorway, purse still on her shoulder, and something inside her quietly shifted.

That night, for the first time since 1983, Marlene turned off the porch light.

It wasn’t dramatic. She didn’t say anything. She just flicked the switch and went to bed.

Two weeks later, Todd moved in with a friend. The house was quieter. The air felt clearer. Marlene started taking evening walks and joined a book club at the library. She began sleeping better.

Her neighbors noticed the porch light stayed off now.

When asked, Marlene would smile and say, “Sometimes, you leave the light off so you can finally rest.”

Love being a grandma?
then you’ll love my daily email.

Every morning I write to 88,500 grandmas to start their day off on the right foot — one warm story with your coffee. It’s uplifting, fun, and always completely free. Give it a try below!

Join the daily letter — it’s free.