Disclaimer: Devoted Grandma is reader-supported. If you purchase anything through my site, I may receive a small commission (at no cost to you). Thank you.
Oh, my dear friend… if there’s one thing we grandmothers love, it’s seeing our grandbabies do the right thing. When they share, when they listen, when they show kindness, it fills our hearts in a way nothing else quite can.
And naturally, we want to reward that goodness.
But here’s the quiet truth many of us learn over time… not all rewards actually help. In fact, some of the most common ways we “reward” our grandkids can slowly shape habits, expectations, and even attitudes that make things harder for them in the long run.
And we don’t mean to, not one bit. Most of us are simply trying to encourage them, to show love, to celebrate those good little moments.
So let’s sit together for a moment and gently look at the ways that can backfire, and what we can do instead to truly nurture the kind of hearts we want them to grow into.
1. Rewarding Everything With Money
There’s something sweet about slipping a few coins or a folded note into a grandchild’s hand. It feels generous, it feels loving… and sometimes it feels like the quickest way to say “well done.”
But when money becomes the main reward for good behavior, it quietly changes the reason behind their actions.
Instead of helping because it’s kind… or listening because it’s respectful… they begin to do things because they expect to be paid.
And before long, you might hear that familiar little question:
“What do I get if I do this?”
That’s when we know something deeper has shifted.
What to do instead:
Let your approval be the reward. A warm smile, a gentle squeeze of the hand, and a sincere “I’m so proud of you” often lingers far longer than money ever will. When we build their inner motivation, we’re giving them something they’ll carry for life.
2. Using Sweets as the Default Reward
Oh, how easy it is to reach for a treat.
A biscuit for sitting nicely. Candy for behaving in the shops. A little something sweet just to keep the peace.
But when sweets become the go-to reward, we begin to link good behavior with sugar. Over time, children may start to associate comfort, success, and even emotional relief with food.
And that’s a habit that can quietly follow them into adulthood.
What to do instead:
Let treats be about joy and togetherness, not transactions. Bake together, share a dessert after dinner, or celebrate something meaningful. Replace “If you’re good, you get sweets” with “Let’s enjoy something special together.”
3. Overpraising for Basic Behavior
Now this one comes straight from the heart.
We see our grandchild do something small, putting away toys, saying “please,” helping a sibling—and we light up with praise.
But when we overpraise every little thing, children can start to expect applause for basic responsibilities.
And when that praise isn’t there, they may hesitate… or feel unsure of themselves.
What to do instead:
Keep your praise gentle and meaningful.
Instead of grand, sweeping compliments, focus on what they did and why it mattered:
“I noticed you helped your sister without being asked. That was very kind.”
That kind of praise builds understanding, not just dependence on approval.
4. Rewarding to Avoid Conflict
Oh, we’ve all been there, tired, overwhelmed, maybe just trying to get through the day peacefully.
“If you behave, I’ll give you this.”
And in that moment, it works.
But over time, children begin to see good behavior as something they offer in exchange for a reward, rather than something that comes from within.
It becomes a deal… not a value.
What to do instead:
Hold your ground calmly. Set expectations with kindness but firmness. Let them understand that behaving well isn’t something they trade, it’s simply part of who they are learning to be.
5. Comparing Them to Others as a Reward
This one slips out so easily.
“You behaved better than your brother today.”
“You’re my good one.”
We think we’re encouraging them… but comparison can quietly plant seeds of competition, insecurity, or even jealousy.
Children don’t just hear praise, they hear ranking. And that can affect how they see themselves and others.
What to do instead:
Celebrate each child for who they are, not how they measure up. Let them feel valued in their own right, without needing to outshine anyone else.
6. Turning Rewards Into Bribes
There’s a quiet but important difference between a reward and a bribe, and it all comes down to timing.
“If you sit quietly, I’ll buy you something.”
Now the behavior isn’t coming from within; it’s being bought in advance.
And children are quick learners. They begin to wait for the offer before they act.
What to do instead:
Let rewards come after the behavior, as a reflection of what they’ve done, not as a promise beforehand. This keeps the focus on their choices, not on what they’ll get.
7. Making Rewards the Only Form of Attention
This one is easy to miss, especially when life gets busy.
If we only give extra attention when our grandkids behave well, they may begin to feel that love is something they have to earn.
And when they’re struggling… they may act out just to get that same attention.
Because to a child, even negative attention can feel better than none at all.
What to do instead:
Show up in the quiet moments, too. Sit beside them while they play. Listen to their stories. Laugh at their little jokes.
Let them feel that your love isn’t tied to performance—it’s simply there.
8. Inconsistent Rewards That Confuse Them
Some days we celebrate a behavior… other days we barely notice it.
Sometimes we reward it generously… sometimes not at all.
To us, it may feel harmless. But to a child, it can feel confusing.
They begin to wonder: Does this matter or not?
And when children are unsure, they often test boundaries, not out of defiance, but out of a need for clarity.
What to do instead:
Be steady. Be predictable. You don’t have to be perfect, just consistent enough that they know what matters and what doesn’t.
9. Making Rewards Replace Values
This is the quietest mistake of all… and perhaps the most important to notice.
When rewards become the focus, the deeper lesson, the kindness, the empathy, the responsibility, can slowly fade into the background.
We don’t just want grandkids who behave well when someone is watching.
We want grandkids with good hearts.
The kind who help because they care.
The kind who speak kindly because it feels right.
What to do instead:
Talk about the why behind their actions.
“Helping your cousin made her feel included.”
“That was a very thoughtful thing to do.”
“You showed patience, and that really matters.”
Those are the seeds of character. And those are the ones that grow.
A Gentle Reminder From One Grandma to Another
At the end of the day, my dear… we’re not trying to raise perfect little performers.
We’re helping shape human beings.
And while rewards can be lovely, they should never replace connection, guidance, and love.
Sometimes the most powerful “reward” is simply sitting beside them and saying,
“I see you. And I’m proud of who you’re becoming.”
Because when all is said and done… the greatest gift we can give our grandkids is not what we hand them—but what we help grow inside them.
And oh, what a beautiful legacy that is.
