Disclaimer: Devoted Grandma is reader-supported. If you purchase anything through my site, I may receive a small commission (at no cost to you). Thank you.
“Other Grandma lets us eat in the living room.”
Well. There you are, holding a plate of carefully sliced apples, discovering that your sofa policy has come under review.
Sometimes the comparison is about cookies. Sometimes it’s about presents, bedtime, or who has the better backyard. And sometimes a perfectly innocent comment manages to poke a tender little place in our grandma hearts.
Do they have more fun there? Do they wish they were visiting her instead?
Children notice differences, and they don’t always cushion their observations. But noticing something they love about another grandmother doesn’t mean they love you less.
While grandkids aren’t necessarily keeping a scorecard at every visit, these are twelve differences they may notice and sometimes announce before they’ve even taken off their shoes.
1. The way each grandma welcomes them
One grandma rushes to the door with open arms. Another calls from the kitchen. One immediately asks about school; another says, “Come see what I’ve saved for you!”
Children may notice whether their arrival feels like a happy occasion or an interruption.
You don’t need balloons and a welcoming committee. A smile, their name, and a sincere “I’m so glad you’re here” can make a lovely beginning.
And if they aren’t ready for a hug, the welcome can still be warm. “Hug, wave, or high five?” gives them room to settle in.
2. The food they look forward to
Apparently, some family recipes come with their own fan club.
“Other Grandma makes the best pancakes.”
That can sting when you’ve been standing at the stove making yours. But children can love her pancakes and your grilled cheese. There’s room in a childhood for more than one favorite meal.
Try asking, “What do you love about them?”
You might learn that she makes tiny ones, lets them flip the last batch, or serves them on a funny plate. Sometimes the treasured part is the experience around the food.
3. The rules they have to follow
Shoes on or off? Snacks upstairs? Toys put away before another game comes out?
Different homes have different expectations, and children are often quick to identify the more generous arrangement.
You can acknowledge the difference without defending your entire household.
“Yes, she allows that at her house. Here, we eat at the table.”
Keep your rules clear and reasonable, and follow the parents’ expectations where they apply. You don’t need to loosen a boundary just because another grandma does things differently.
4. How much they get away with
This is slightly different from comparing rules. Children may also notice what happens when they push them.
Does repeated asking eventually produce a yes? Does pouting earn an extra treat? Will Grandma quietly allow something Mom already refused?
Being the grandma who can be persuaded might bring a moment of popularity, but it can make visits harder to manage.
A calm response helps: “I know you’re disappointed, sweetheart. My answer is still no.”
You can be affectionate while holding a boundary. You don’t have to win every smile.
5. The presents and spending money
One grandmother may arrive with shopping bags. Another may have a tighter budget and bring a library book she thought they would enjoy.
Children can notice the difference, especially before they understand what things cost.
If your grandchild mentions an expensive gift, you can simply say, “That sounds exciting! Have you tried it yet?”
You don’t owe them a matching purchase. Build familiar pleasures that fit your life: choosing a bedtime story, making popcorn, or taking your usual walk together.
Let your time together be something they can count on.
6. What there is to do
One grandma has a swimming pool. Another lives near a playground. One plans outings; another enjoys quiet afternoons at home.
It’s understandable if children get excited about an experience you can’t offer.
Instead of trying to recreate her visits, look for something you can enjoy together. Perhaps you teach them a card game, plant something in a pot, or let them photograph interesting things on a walk.
You can also ask, “What’s one thing you’d like us to do today?”
A small choice can help them feel involved in the visit.
7. How closely each grandma listens
Children may notice who lets them finish a story, who remembers their friend’s name, and who looks up when they begin talking.
They may also notice when every conversation turns into advice.
I think many of us have to resist preparing our helpful answer before a grandchild has finished the first sentence.
Try a simple follow-up: “And then what happened?”
You don’t have to understand every detail of their game, friendship, or school project. Giving them a few minutes of interested attention makes space for them to share more.
8. How comfortable they feel in the house
Some homes have a cupboard children can open, a place to leave their things, and somewhere comfortable to curl up.
Other homes may feel full of objects they’re afraid to touch.
You don’t need to hand over the house or risk treasured possessions. A small basket of activities and a clear explanation of what they can use may be enough.
“This drawer is for you, and you can use anything inside.”
That little invitation can help a child relax without leaving you worried about your best china.
9. What happens when they make a mistake
A spilled drink can become a quick cleanup or a story that gets repeated at every family gathering.
Grandkids may remember which response they received.
When something goes wrong, begin with what needs to happen next. “Let’s get a towel” gives everyone something useful to do.
There may still be a lesson or a consequence, especially if they ignored a clear instruction. But embarrassment doesn’t need to become part of it.
And when we overreact, we can repair it: “I spoke too sharply. I’m sorry.”
10. How they feel around the other grandchildren
Children may compare who gets the longest turn, whose interests shape the afternoon, or who always seems to receive praise.
They may say, “Other Grandma lets me choose sometimes.”
That’s worth hearing before assuming they’re only trying to get their way.
You can ask, “Have you felt like you haven’t had a turn?”
Fairness doesn’t always mean identical treatment, but each child needs opportunities to be considered. Letting one choose the game and another choose the snack can help. So can a few minutes of individual attention.
11. Whether their growing independence is respected
One grandma still orders for them at a restaurant. Another asks what they would like. One uses a childhood nickname they’ve outgrown; another remembers their request to stop.
As grandkids grow, they may become especially aware of these differences.
We can keep our affection while updating our habits.
“Would you like help, or do you want to try?”
“What would you prefer I call you?”
Giving them age-appropriate choices shows that we’re paying attention to who they are becoming, even when part of us still pictures them in footed pajamas.
12. How each grandma reacts to hearing about the other
This comparison can be easy to overlook.
Can your grandchild happily tell you about baking with their other grandma? Or do they sense that they should leave out the good parts to protect your feelings?
We may feel a little jealousy. That doesn’t make us unkind; it gives us a feeling to handle thoughtfully.
“That sounds like a lovely afternoon. What did you bake?”
A warm response lets your grandchild share their life freely. They shouldn’t have to make one grandmother sound less wonderful to reassure the other.
The next time you hear “Other Grandma does it differently,” take a breath before deciding what it means. Your grandchild may be making an observation, asking for something, or offering a small clue about what matters to them.
Listen to the clue. Keep the boundaries you need. Enjoy the things that belong to your relationship.
And if the other grandma really does make extraordinary pancakes, perhaps she’ll share the recipe.
