Disclaimer: Devoted Grandma is reader-supported. If you purchase anything through my site, I may receive a small commission (at no cost to you). Thank you.
As grandmothers, we play a special role in our grandchildren’s lives. We’re often seen as the warm embrace after a scraped knee, the cheerleader after a hard day at school, and sometimes even the gentle bridge between a parent’s “no” and a child’s disappointment. But every now and then, the time comes when we have to step in and correct behavior. And while discipline is a necessary part of helping children grow into respectful and responsible adults, how we go about it matters more than we sometimes realize.
Here are the worst disciplining tactics we should avoid at all costs—and why staying away from them will protect our precious bond with our grandchildren.
1. Shaming or Humiliating the Child
Statements like “You’re acting like a baby” or “What’s wrong with you?” might slip out in moments of frustration, but they can do lasting damage. Children internalize these messages quickly. Instead of correcting behavior, we end up planting seeds of insecurity and shame.
What to do instead: Speak to the behavior, not the child. “That was unkind” is far healthier than “You’re a mean child.”
2. Bringing Up Past Mistakes
Rehashing every wrong thing your grandchild has ever done (“You always do this!” or “Remember last time you messed up too?”) only teaches them that their past defines them. Children need space to grow, not be trapped by their history.
What to do instead: Address the moment. Say, “Let’s focus on what happened now and how we can do better going forward.”
3. Threatening Without Follow Through
“If you don’t behave, I’m never buying you anything again!” We’ve all said something we didn’t mean, but idle threats confuse children and damage your credibility. They’ll either live in fear or stop taking you seriously.
What to do instead: Set reasonable, clear consequences that you can actually follow through on, and stick to them gently but firmly.
4. Comparing Them to Others
“Your cousin would never act like this,” or “Why can’t you be more like your brother?” These comments create sibling rivalry, resentment, and low self-worth. Each child is their own little person—beautifully unique.
What to do instead: Focus on their strengths and growth. Say things like, “You’re learning. I know you can make a better choice next time.”
5. Using Physical Punishment
Some of us were raised in a time when spanking was normal. But we now know that physical discipline doesn’t teach kids why something is wrong—it just teaches them to fear getting caught. It also risks harming trust and creating a cycle of aggression.
What to do instead: Use calm conversations, natural consequences, and time-outs as a way to let children reflect.
6. Silent Treatment or Withholding Affection
Children are emotionally vulnerable. If you suddenly go cold or ignore them because you’re upset, they may feel deeply rejected or confused. Love should never feel conditional to a child.
What to do instead: You can be disappointed in their behavior and still show warmth. “I love you, but I’m not happy with what you did” is a powerful balance.
7. Embarrassing Them in Front of Others
Correcting them loudly in public, making sarcastic remarks, or pointing out their flaws in front of friends or siblings only leads to humiliation. Children value their dignity—even the little ones.
What to do instead: If a correction is needed, pull them aside quietly. Keep the moment private, respectful, and supportive.
8. Overreacting Emotionally
If we yell, cry, or become overly dramatic when a child misbehaves, we end up teaching them that big reactions are normal responses to conflict. It also shifts the focus from their mistake to our reaction.
What to do instead: Take a breath. Step away for a moment if needed. A calm response teaches emotional regulation far better than a dramatic one.
9. Bribing Instead of Teaching
Offering candy, money, or gifts to stop bad behavior might fix the moment—but it won’t fix the behavior. Bribes teach children to act right only when there’s something in it for them.
What to do instead: Praise effort, not results. Reinforce good behavior because it’s the right thing, not because it earns a reward.
10. Overdisciplining for Accidents
Spilled milk, lost toys, or breaking something by mistake are not misbehaviors. Punishing children for accidents only teaches them to hide things and be afraid of making honest mistakes.
What to do instead: Show grace. Use these moments to teach responsibility. “Let’s clean it up together. Accidents happen, but we always help fix them.”
11. Punishing Without Explanation
Children don’t always understand why something is wrong, and punishing without explaining just leaves them confused. They may behave differently—but not because they understand why.
What to do instead: Take a moment to explain. “We don’t speak like that because it hurts people’s feelings. Let’s talk about better ways to express yourself.”
12. Taking Everything Away
Some grandmas might feel tempted to take away all toys, devices, or fun activities to make a point. But extreme punishments like these often feel like overkill and can backfire emotionally.
What to do instead: Choose one or two privileges and connect them directly to the behavior. “If you can’t use kind words, we’ll take a break from video games until tomorrow.”
13. Making the Child Feel Like a Burden
Saying things like, “You’re stressing me out!” or “I can’t handle you today” places adult emotions on little shoulders. Children should never feel like they’re too much to love.
What to do instead: If you’re overwhelmed, take a break or ask another adult for help. Let your grandchild know, “Grandma needs a little quiet time, but I still love being with you.”
14. Correcting Every Little Thing
Children are learning. If we nitpick every noise, movement, or fidget, we’ll wear them down emotionally and make them anxious around us.
What to do instead: Pick your battles. Focus on what truly matters, and let the small stuff go with a chuckle and a hug.
Final Thoughts
We grandmothers have something precious: a chance to be a soft landing and a guiding hand. Discipline doesn’t have to look like punishment. It can look like redirection, conversation, boundary-setting, and a whole lot of love.
When we choose gentleness over harshness, patience over punishment, and connection over control, we raise grandchildren who not only behave well—but feel safe, seen, and truly loved. And isn’t that what being a grandma is really all about?
